Keep a carton-level count sheet as you reconcile what arrived against what the packing list expected.

The packing list says 40 cartons. The truck delivers 37. That is enough to trigger a message, but not enough to prove a supplier shortage. This is an illustrative receiving scene, not a customer case. In trade terms, a short shipment, or short delivery, means the quantity received is below the documented expectation, and the label covers two different counts. Thirty-seven cartons against 40 is a carton shortage. Forty cartons with one holding 20 units instead of 24 is a unit-level short receipt.

Reconcile before you claim. Compare four records, count cartons before units, recount on the same basis, mark the delivery receipt before signing, photograph what you see and keep the packaging. Then send a written notice naming the PO, invoice, delivery date, affected carton IDs and SKU-level ordered, received and outstanding quantities. Your route and deadline depend on the sale contract, transport document, carrier terms and insurance policy.

Shipment shortage meaning: a carton shortage is different from a unit shortage

A carton shortage means fewer cartons arrive than the packing list or delivery documents say. A unit shortage means the expected cartons arrive, but one or more hold fewer products than expected. One warehouse guide uses 19 cartons delivered against 20 as a carton shortage, and 20 cartons with one holding fewer products as a unit-level discrepancy. See the OS&D guide.

Do not stop at a net difference. Suppose you ordered 100 cartons; 80 arrive, two are damaged and not accepted, and 20 have not been delivered. Those are four separate quantities: received, accepted, rejected and outstanding. Receiving 80 with two rejected is not the same as receiving 78. The delivery-note guide explains why the labels must stay apart.

Use one quantity basis at a time. Pieces, sets, cartons and pallets are not interchangeable without a verified pack-size rule; ten cartons and ten individual items are not comparable. The same guide makes that point directly.

A count difference is an observation. Fault is a separate question. A carrier may be responsible for a loss during transport, but it is not automatically liable for every count discrepancy: a supplier packing error, an incorrect purchase order or an internal receiving mistake can produce the same result. The OS&D guide puts it plainly. Keep what was counted separate from why it happened and what remedy is owed.

Short delivery meaning: four records establish what should have arrived

A short delivery is a comparison between what was agreed, what was billed, what was packed and what was received. Build that baseline before you recount.

A woman resting both hands on a taped cardboard shipping carton with a white label, beside a laptop and tape dispenser at a packing table.

A cardboard shipping carton on a packing table, ready for a delivery check.

Record What it helps check What it cannot prove alone
Order confirmation Each variant and quantity, allowed mix, product and packaging specifications, extra charges, stock balances and delivery schedule What was physically loaded
Commercial invoice The sale, billed units and customs value The physical pack-out inside each carton
Carton-level packing list Carton identity, SKU allocation, units per carton, net and gross weights, revision date Whether every carton matches its description
Signed delivery receipt or delivery note What the recipient accepted, rejected or received short A unit-by-unit count of sealed cartons

The invoice records the sale and customs value, the packing list records the physical pack-out, and the bill of lading records the carrier's receipt and carriage. Each has a different job, and the three should not be forced into identical values. This document comparison explains the split. A delivery note sits later in the physical flow and can capture what the recipient accepted, rejected or received short. It is not the carrier's bill of lading.

Open the order confirmation first. For a shortage baseline you need its approved variants and quantities, the mix the supplier was allowed to ship, product and packaging specifications, extra charges, stock balances and delivery schedule. Check that total against both the invoice and your purchase order. Surmount's MOQ guide gives that checklist in plain terms.

The packing list should be carton-level, not just a shipment total. Ask for carton ranges, SKU allocations, units per carton, clearly separated net and gross weights and a revision date, so an earlier estimate is not mistaken for the final record. Yunxi's import checklist lists those fields. Match lines by SKU, not row position, so the comparison survives a different line order, and give a partial shipment its own allocation rather than comparing it with the full purchase-order quantity. Reducto's reconciliation guide covers both points.

Trace each invoice line to specific packages where you can, because a shipment-level total alone may conceal a missing SKU. Yunxi warns about that directly. A documentary review still cannot establish the contents of sealed cartons from a carton count. If unit quantities remain disputed, agree the scope of an authorised count or inspection: which cartons will be opened, who witnesses it, and what the findings will cover. A warehouse service limited to carton counting and exterior checks is not product inspection, so if you need cartons opened, units counted, inspected or repacked, agree the scope and price separately. Surmount's consolidation guide makes that distinction.

Reconcile carton IDs first, then units by SKU

Treat carton IDs as the handling-count spine. Before product counting, list every ID on the dock and mark duplicates, missing labels or unreadable marks. If an ID cannot be resolved, put that carton in a held group and record it as outstanding. Do not let it disappear into a clean carton total. The written notice should inherit the same ID and status, or the warehouse and supplier will work from different maps. Surmount's carton-mark guide treats ID reconciliation as the first receiving step, not the final one.

A complete carton count still leaves variant and unit questions open. Receiving the expected number of cartons does not by itself establish that all units or the correct variants arrived, which is why the shortage notice needs both a carton section and a SKU section. The same guide shows the arithmetic.

A mixed carton appears on two SKU rows but remains one handling unit. Count cartons from carton IDs and units from SKU rows. Record a partially filled last carton at its actual quantity, not the standard pack quantity, then check each SKU against the quantities approved for that shipment. Surmount's packing-list example covers that.

Repacking changes references. If a consolidation warehouse splits one carton into two, the carton count rises while the product total may stay the same. Close the old carton reference, assign distinct references to the replacement boxes and record the old-to-new link. In the receipt exception, name the old ID and the new IDs, and keep the SKU quantity tied to the product rather than the number of boxes. Two active cartons should never carry the same ID. Surmount covers that handover control.

Quantity short received: run a controlled recount, then route the gap

When the received quantity falls short, the next step is a controlled recount.

Define the expected receipt on one basis: order revision, model or specification, delivery-batch reference, receiving location, date and time zone, and counting owner. Do not compare one partial delivery with the whole order quantity. CZ Overseas lays out that starting record.

Use a fictional example. The confirmed expected receipt is 1,000 pieces of one revision in this delivery. The warehouse separates other batches and recounts 980 pieces. That leaves 20 pieces on the same basis. The number is a count difference. It does not prove underpacking, theft, liability or a recoverable value. CZ Overseas uses exactly that illustration.

Warehouse worker holding a clipboard beside cardboard cartons on a receiving counter

A receiving check records the cartons and units counted at the counter before any shortage claim is prepared.

If a carton remains unopened, another location is unchecked or a split delivery is unresolved, keep the receipt pending. Unknown is not zero. Retain the first count, the recount and the reason for any correction, and do not overwrite the first record with a clean total.

Where the outer carton count is correct but units are missing, examine the supplier's packing records and your own receiving count before assuming transport loss. A signature confirming receipt of pallets is not a unit-level inventory count of sealed cartons. The Dollan OS&D guide makes both cautions.

The packing list is prepared before loading and states what should have arrived by model and carton count. A loading tally, counted at the door while the container was filled, is the last count taken while the goods were still under the seller's control. If the tally shows fewer cartons than the packing list, the shortfall happened before the container closed. If the tally shows the cartons were loaded and the seal number matches, a missing carton becomes a delivery or receiving question. This short-shipment-or-breakage guide explains why the tally decides a carton-level shortage.

A matching seal is not proof of an undamaged load. It shows the container was not opened, not that the contents were handled well. Look for cartons that have been re-taped, re-stacked or moved out of their original stow position, because a tidy outer count can hide breakage.

What you see First question to route
Whole cartons missing Carrier or delivery question, subject to the transport document
Cartons present but short-packed Supplier packing or handover question
Wet, crushed or otherwise damaged cartons Cargo insurer or carrier, not automatically a supplier shortage

Anabyn's route table separates transit damage, shortage and quality faults, and makes clear that the final paying party is not automatic.

Shipment received short: annotate before you sign, then photograph

At handover, check handling-unit labels, watch for shortages during unloading and count the actual handling units. GetTent's receiving instructions put those three checks at delivery. Where practicable, compare actual unit IDs and count with the inventory and transport document. GetTransport's receiving guide recommends the same comparison.

Write a specific exception on both the driver's copy and your copy: affected carton IDs, the condition you observed and the shortfall. "Subject to inspection" is weaker than a factual description, and a generic note may not adequately document an observable shortage or damage. The Dollan guide and GetTransport both make that point.

A receiver holding a clipboard checks a pallet of sealed cartons inside an open delivery trailer at a loading dock, with blank forms on a nearby table

At the trailer door, a receiver with a clipboard checks a pallet of sealed cartons while paperwork waits on the table.

Your signature can carry the notation "received subject to discrepancy." Ask the driver to initial or acknowledge the notation on your copy. If the driver refuses, note the refusal on the receipt. DohAssist's short-ship guide treats driver acknowledgment as a credit-process accelerator, not a guarantee.

Photograph the annotated receipt, the delivered goods, the packaging and each damaged carton identifier before you decide whether to open a damaged carton, and retain the original files. Give each photo a job: it should support a specific line in the receipt exception, identify a carton named in the notice or answer the question that still blocks the count. Surmount's consolidation guide recommends recording the identifier, damage and handover details before opening; DohAssist describes timestamped photographs as strong evidence for a later credit review.

One manufacturer's published freight-receiving policy shows how strict a clean signature can be. Under its terms, the recipient's signature on a delivery receipt or bill of lading constitutes acceptance "as is" and in good order, and concealed damage must be reported to the company arranging the shipment within five days, with a carrier claim filed. Read that as that company's policy, not a universal legal deadline for every China shipment. WB Manufacturing's policy is the example. A clean signature does not automatically decide liability under your contract.

Build a dated short shipment file before you escalate

Keep the original transport document, commercial invoice, carton-level packing list, purchase order or order revision, signed delivery receipt or proof of delivery, and any loading tally or seal record in the form received. Do not silently replace originals with a corrected spreadsheet. This audit-ready packet method explains why source records and later corrections should both be retained.

Add the first count and recount record, photographs linked to carton IDs, the supplier's explanation, buyer approval, and a corrected invoice or supporting adjustment plus a revised packing list if the quantity changes. Yunxi's checklist lists that evidence set.

Cost the loss from the invoice value and the affected units. Keep the goods and packaging until the claim closes. Do not scrap, repair or sell affected units without written agreement, because destroying evidence weakens recovery. Globalior's cargo-claim guide sets out the file and the preservation point.

Record what is confirmed, what remains unknown, who is checking each question and when the next update is due. A complete file is evidence, and it still does not establish liability or guarantee compensation. CZ Overseas states that limit clearly.

Write a specific supplier notice, not a vague complaint

A shortage notice is a formal written letter sent after a delivery is found to contain fewer items than the purchase order or invoice states. It is a record request, not a legal determination. Business in a Box's template guide describes it that way.

Use a subject line with the PO number, invoice number and delivery date. Put sender and recipient details in the body, and send it to the supplier's dispatch or accounts contact rather than only to a sales representative, because the wrong recipient can delay internal routing by days. The same guide covers both points.

Here is a buyer-drafted structure. Replace every bracketed field; this is not contract wording or legal advice.

Subject: Short shipment notice, PO [PO number] / Invoice [invoice number] / Delivery [date]

We received the shipment above on [date] at [location]. Our count against the packing list is set out below.

SKU Ordered Received Outstanding
[SKU] [qty] [qty] [qty]

Affected carton IDs: [list]. Partial carton: [ID and actual quantity, if any].

Attached: packing slip, our goods receipt note, receiving photographs and inspection photographs.

We request that you either deliver the outstanding units by [date] or issue a credit note for [amount] against Invoice [number] within [number] business days. Please confirm your chosen course of action by [date]. If we do not receive a response by that date, [state the specific consequence you are prepared to apply].

Confirmed count difference: [quantity by SKU]. Still being checked: [cause or missing input]. Next update: [date].

List the shortfall item by item with SKU, ordered quantity, received quantity and outstanding quantity, attach the packing slip, your goods receipt note and inspection photographs, and reference affected carton IDs and any partial carton. Business in a Box gives that structure.

Request a remedy with a date: deliver outstanding units by a stated date or issue a credit note for the shortfall. Set a response deadline and state a specific consequence, rather than a vague threat. Keep the confirmed count difference separate from the suspected cause and the proposed remedy, and tell the other party who is checking what and when the next update is planned. CZ Overseas recommends that separation in progress updates.

Send promptly after inspection. One commercial template vendor suggests 24 to 48 hours, but that is the vendor's recommended practice, not a universal rule for China supplier orders. Check your purchase order, sale contract and carrier terms. Business in a Box also warns that if the supplier's records show full dispatch, the question may shift to the carrier or forwarder. Do not threaten to withhold payment for delivered goods without checking the contract.

Notice deadlines and claim routes depend on your documents

Every carriage regime can have two separate clocks: a short notice period for telling the carrier about loss or damage, and a longer time bar for formal proceedings. Missing either one can end the claim. Globalior states the two-clock problem directly.

The exact periods depend on transport mode, the applicable convention or national law, the transport document and any contract clause that shortens the period. Read the actual document rather than assuming one number. Globalior makes that instruction explicit.

US interstate motor carriage is one example. Federal rules describe a minimum nine-month claim-filing period and a two-year suit period measured from the carrier's written disallowance of part of the claim. The Freight Guru's deadlines guide gives those examples. US-related ocean shipments generally fall under COGSA and international air shipments under international conventions, with their own notice requirements and limitation periods.

One freight provider's concealed-loss instructions use 48 hours for carrier notice and 7 days for notice to that provider. Those are that company's instructions, not a universal standard. GetTent's claims page is the example.

A claim may run against the carrier under the contract of carriage, your cargo insurer, the seller under the sale contract or a warehouse or handling agent. Those routes have different proof burdens, limits and remedies. Globalior separates them. Where several rules apply, use the shortest applicable timeline as an operational deadline while you check the actual service, route, contract and current instructions. Racklify recommends that discipline.

Before you write the supplier

Do the boring part in order: reconcile carton IDs against the packing list, recount units by SKU on the same basis, annotate the delivery receipt before signing, photograph the evidence and keep the packaging. Then send a short notice that names the PO, invoice, delivery date, affected carton IDs and SKU-level ordered, received and outstanding quantities, with a specific remedy and response deadline.

A clean signature, a matching seal, a complete file or a 48-hour figure does not settle liability on its own. Your contract, transport document and carrier terms decide the route and deadline. Send this receiving checklist to whoever counts your next delivery, and fix the packing-list template before the next shipment leaves. If you are still preparing the order, start with our guides to carton shipping marks and packing lists and consolidating orders from multiple China suppliers.